Peterson v/s Manning

[jjtweeks]

Who do you think it should be.
For me it isn't really that close. I think their comeback stories are pretty much the same(both unbelievable). Peterson dominated all RB's while on a team where the running game was the only threat. The defense knew what to focus on and still could not do much to stop him. Peyton was amazing but was on a much better team with star wideouts. Thats my 2 cents

 

[German CTL]

Peterson for me. What he did this year coming off that injury was absolutely amazing. A season for the ages IMO.

 

[cctekguy]

Agreed.

Peyton's comeback was impressive but I don't think he equaled his previous level.

Peterson was as good or better than he has ever been.

 

[nicholete]

Peterson!

 

[Phicinfan]

I lean Peterson only because as stated above he outperformed everyone, even his past excellence. P.Manning is a great story as well, but what Peterson did was simply amazing.

 

[deuce4321]

Arguments can be made for Peterson for not only comeback player of the year but MVP as well. What say you?

 

[nicholete]

I agree he could win both but won't. had that ever happened? My guess is no.

 

[bobbeaux]

peterson for mvp . . . manning for comeback . . .

 

[jjtweeks]

peterson for mvp . . . manning for comeback . . .

yep

 

[nicholete]

Just give him both. He deserves it!

 

[Miller]

Peterson for MVP, and not close. however, I don't think he shwould be comeback player of the year. he only missed a part of a season. Manning came back from much more.

 

[mudloggerone]

Great point Miller.

 

[gizzil]

Yeah Miller hits it