Questions, questions, questions..

wical34

wical34

My reality check bounced.
Just a post to find a consensus..

We will make the setting 1/2pt PPR, Points are to the decimal. I.E - 1 yd is .01 pt. Redraft league..
Passing TD's 4 pts
Rushing/Receiving 6pts
Passing yards 25yd - 1pt

QB
RG3 - Wilson
Peyton Manning - Tom Brady
Andrew Luck - Matt Stafford
Colin Kaepernick - Cam Newton
Andy Dalton - Jay Cutler
Eli Manning - Tony Romo

WR
Eric Decker -Wes Welker
Golden Tate - Stevie Johnson
Marques Colston - Victor Cruz
Mike Williams - Lance Moore
Desean Jackson - Torrey Smith
Sidney Rice - Anquan Boldin

RB
Frank Gore - Maurice Jones-Drew
Reggie Bush - Matt Forte
Ahmad Bradshaw - DeAngelo Williams
Darren McFadden - DeMarco Murray
CJ Spiller - LeSean McCoy
Ray Rice - Trent Richardson
David Wilson - Stevan Ridley

Just a few combo's I would be interested in knowing what the views of most are..
 
Are you axing us to choose one of each pair, or rank the tandems best to worst, or what?

The title says, "Questions, Questions, Questions..." but I don't see a single question here.

Well, except for mine, of course.
 
QB
RG3 - Wilson
Peyton Manning - Tom Brady
Andrew Luck - Matt Stafford
Colin Kaepernick - Cam Newton
Andy Dalton - Jay Cutler
Eli Manning - Tony Romo Oh I don't want either but I'll say Eli
WR
Eric Decker -Wes Welker
Golden Tate - Stevie Johnson
Marques Colston - Victor Cruz
Mike Williams - Lance Moore
Desean Jackson - Torrey Smith
Sidney Rice - Anquan Boldin Easy one with Boldin out of action :)
RB
Frank Gore - Maurice Jones-Drew
Reggie Bush - Matt Forte
Ahmad Bradshaw - DeAngelo Williams
Darren McFadden - DeMarco Murray
CJ Spiller - LeSean McCoy
Ray Rice - Trent Richardson
David Wilson - Stevan Ridley
 
Touche Alf..

This is a would you rather have scenario. Please choose one of each pair.
 
wical34 said:
Just a post to find a consensus..

We will make the setting 1/2pt PPR, Points are to the decimal. I.E - 1 yd is .01 pt. Redraft league..
Passing TD's 4 pts
Rushing/Receiving 6pts
Passing yards 25yd - 1pt
Click to expand...
okay lets see what we see....
wical34 said:
QB
RG3 - Wilson
Peyton Manning - Tom Brady
Andrew Luck - Matt Stafford
Colin Kaepernick - Cam Newton
Andy Dalton - Jay Cutler
Eli Manning - Tony Romo
Click to expand...
Wilson over RG3 - why? Health. Washington needs RG3 to run to win, Seattle does not. I think RG will miss some time again, and as such will not be as high a scorer as Wilson.
Manning over Brady - Weapons, Manning has em, Brady doesn't.
Luck - Stafford - gonna call this in favor of Stafford, thanks to Bush and Megatron
Kaep vs. Newton - gonna go Cam, as I think San Fran will rely on run more, and Carolina's run game doesn't look good.
Dalton - Cutler - Cutler. Dalton is okay, but Cutler will have huge games, I don't think Dalton will.
Manning vs. Romo - Romo as Manning looks to be regressing, and not sure if Nicks and Cruz will survive all year.

wical34 said:
WR
Eric Decker -Wes Welker
Golden Tate - Stevie Johnson
Marques Colston - Victor Cruz
Mike Williams - Lance Moore
Desean Jackson - Torrey Smith
Sidney Rice - Anquan Boldin
Click to expand...
Decker vs. Welker - Welker - will be slot and will be pet for Manning. Decker loses alot of ground IMO this year.
Tate - Stevie - gotta go Stevie - he IS the WR in Bufallo, and they will be throwing alot to try and catch up.
Colston and Cruz is tough for me, if Nicks survives I love Cruz as the uncovered #2, but if Nicks is out again, Colston may be better.
M.Williams vs. Moore - no contest M.Williams. #2 and maybe #1 wr in N.O. is Graham, Moore is #3 option, #4 if Sproles is back in favor
D.Jackson vs. Torrey Smith - Djax - he will be the key in a high power off. Smith will be target to cover, and won't be as free deep as in the past IMO
Rice vs. Boldin - Yikes this is tough. Boldin IS the man now in San Fran, and Rice is already dinged up. Gonna go Boldin here.

wical34 said:
RB
Frank Gore - Maurice Jones-Drew
Reggie Bush - Matt Forte
Ahmad Bradshaw - DeAngelo Williams
Darren McFadden - DeMarco Murray
CJ Spiller - LeSean McCoy
Ray Rice - Trent Richardson
David Wilson - Stevan Ridley
Click to expand...
Gore vs. MJD - I think MJD comes back with passion to prove folks he is healthy, and San Fran takes some carries from Gore to lighten load.
Bush vs. Forte - gonna go against the grain and say Bush. He will be a PPR monster, and Cutler hasn't sold me yet he is ready to do that with Forte.
Bradshaw vs. D.Williams - Bradshaw, if healthy on that team he will be huge. Dwill just doesn't look good right now.
McFadden vs. Murray - will predict this as a tie, as neither will last all year. Book it.
Spiller vs. McCoy - going McCoy. Spiller will be THE offense in Buf. but they aren't good, and will have to pass more, and I think Kelly has a huge off. for McCoy.
Rice vs. Richardson - Rice all day every day, he is the offense, even with Pierce. Richardson to me is gonna get stuffed and hurt.
Wilson vs. Ridley - I think Ridley here. PPR helps neither, and I think Ridley will be the run game in N.E.
 
Mud and Phic a little contradicting.. I like it!

Phicinfan said:
Decker vs. Welker - Welker - will be slot and will be pet for Manning. Decker loses alot of ground IMO this year.
Tate - Stevie - gotta go Stevie - he IS the WR in Bufallo, and they will be throwing alot to try and catch up.
Colston and Cruz is tough for me, if Nicks survives I love Cruz as the uncovered #2, but if Nicks is out again, Colston may be better.
M.Williams vs. Moore - no contest M.Williams. #2 and maybe #1 wr in N.O. is Graham, Moore is #3 option, #4 if Sproles is back in favor
D.Jackson vs. Torrey Smith - Djax - he will be the key in a high power off. Smith will be target to cover, and won't be as free deep as in the past IMO
Rice vs. Boldin - Yikes this is tough. Boldin IS the man now in San Fran, and Rice is already dinged up. Gonna go Boldin here.
Click to expand...

I may disagree with all of these - Lol

Decker is a true talent just out-shined by Demaryius IMO. Welker doesn't have a nose for the end zone. I predicted Decker will be the Reggie Wayne to Marvin Harrison. With Welker taking the Austin Collie role.
Golden Tate and Stevie is really close to me. I just like Tates offense a lot better. Not to mention Rice is one wrong step from being out again.
Colston and Cruz is incredibly tough. In PPR both had 5 games over 20 pts, the rest were stat lines around 4-70.
I like Moore over Mike Williams.. Still don't trust Freeman at QB and think Moore fills in nicely as the uncovered guy for Brees.
I agree with DJax for the same reasons.
Boldin - He's tough and way under rated this season.
 
QB
RG3 - Wilson Top scoring QB over the second half of 2012.
Peyton Manning - Tom Brady Has Brady's best WR.
Andrew Luck - Matt Stafford More TDs this season.
Colin Kaepernick - Cam Newton Kaep will run more; Cam will run less.
Andy Dalton - Jay Cutler Yuck.
Eli Manning - Tony Romo By a Cowboys-Stadium-sized mile.

WR
Eric Decker -Wes Welker Still the red zone target, but PPR scoring makes it closer.
Golden Tate - Stevie Johnson Only experienced receiver vs. #2 on a more diversified offense.
Marques Colston - Victor Cruz See above.
Mike Williams - Lance Moore More of a red zone target.
Desean Jackson - Torrey Smith Smith may have similar yardage on fewer catches, so gimme DJax in a PPR.
Sidney Rice - Anquan Boldin Again on the PPR basis.

RB
Frank Gore - Maurice Jones-Drew More of a featured back.
Reggie Bush - Matt Forte Could break the RB record for receptions this year (101 for Larry Centers in 1995).
Ahmad Bradshaw - DeAngelo Williams Panthers' running game is in shambles.
Darren McFadden - DeMarco Murray The Raiders' running game may be worse.
CJ Spiller - LeSean McCoy Flip a coin. Neither one will be top 10. McCoy has better odds of staying healthy.
Ray Rice - Trent Richardson The only guy in his backfield.
David Wilson - Stevan Ridley Not even close. 12 TDs to 4.
 
Axe Elf said:
Eh, still 12 TDs to 6. I'll still take Ridley.
Click to expand...
Wilson has to get a bump for receptions now too tho. 30+ is certainly not out of the question.

I think 6 TDs is an awfully low expectation for the lead RB on an above average offense in the NFL too. Andre Brown had 8 TDs by himself in this offense in 2012. No reason Wilson can't hit that number or even eclipse it.
 
Wilson will probly still get pulled at the goalline a lot though--it will just be Torain taking them in 'stead of Brown.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top