Keep 7 ! who would you ???

H

Hail Mary

New Member
10 team deep keeper league / standard scoring / non ppr / start 1 qb , 2 rb ,2 wr , 1 te , 1 k , def . If you had to choose today who which 7 would you keep ?? Thinking about trading some players for picks ,, I want to see what Uall WOULD BE thinking ?? your thoughts are greatly appreciated ! Hmary :grin:

QB Brett Favre MIN
QB Eli Manning NYG
RB Pierre Thomas NO
RB Ronnie Brown MIA
RB Steve Slaton HOU
RB Tim Hightower ARZ
RB Willis McGahee BAL
RB Michael Bush OAK
WR Greg Jennings GB
WR Dwayne Bowe KC
WR Hakeem Nicks NYG
WR Michael Crabtree SF
TE Greg Olsen CHI 5
TDSP Buffalo Bills
 
7 huh? That's a lot.

I would rank your players like this

1. Greg Jennings
2. Michael Crabtree
3. Pierre Thomas
4. Ronnie Brown
5. Dwayne Bowe
6. Hakeem Nicks
7. Tim Hightower (or Michael Bush they're even imo)


I assume that in a 10 team league you can pick up a decent QB in the draft even if it is 7 keepers. Don't know if that helps or not but that's what I think :)
 
Nice list Chris.

I'd give Crabs more long term value in a keeper league than Jennings but wtf....he can keep 7 so who cares.
 
Hail Mary said:
10 team deep keeper league / standard scoring / non ppr / start 1 qb , 2 rb ,2 wr , 1 te , 1 k , def . If you had to choose today who which 7 would you keep ?? Thinking about trading some players for picks ,, I want to see what Uall WOULD BE thinking ?? your thoughts are greatly appreciated ! Hmary :grin:

QB Brett Favre MIN
QB Eli Manning NYG
RB Pierre Thomas NO
RB Ronnie Brown MIA
RB Steve Slaton HOU
RB Tim Hightower ARZ
RB Willis McGahee BAL
RB Michael Bush OAK
WR Greg Jennings GB
WR Dwayne Bowe KC
WR Hakeem Nicks NYG
WR Michael Crabtree SF
TE Greg Olsen CHI 5
TDSP Buffalo Bills
Click to expand...

I'd keep these guys.
 
<acronym title="quarterback"></acronym> The guys in bold I would keep. The other 3 listed would compete for my last spot. At this point I would lean Bush just b/c I think he has a better shot at being the man than Hightower who I see losing more to Wells this year. But they are close, Hightower is likely the safer of the two though. As far as safe, Manning is the safe pick, but I agree with Chris, even if everyone keeps a QB, still leaves you with plenty to choose from and i don't consider Manning a top 10 QB, you'll do just as good in the draft here IMO.

<acronym title="quarterback">QB</acronym> Eli Manning NYG
<acronym title="Running Back">RB</acronym> Pierre Thomas NO
<acronym title="Running Back">RB</acronym> Ronnie Brown MIA <acronym title="Running Back"></acronym>
<acronym title="Running Back">RB</acronym> Tim Hightower ARZ <acronym title="Running Back"></acronym>
<acronym title="Running Back">RB</acronym> Michael Bush OAK
<acronym title="Wide Receiver">WR</acronym> Greg Jennings GB
<acronym title="Wide Receiver">WR</acronym> Dwayne Bowe KC
<acronym title="Wide Receiver">WR</acronym> Hakeem Nicks NYG
<acronym title="Wide Receiver">WR</acronym> Michael Crabtree SF
<acronym title="tight end"></acronym>


​
 
No disrespect to all you FF master minds but i dont think Ronnie Brown (many knee problems) should be kept

I agree with the rest of Miller's picks
 
10 teams, 7 keepers= 70 keepers. In Shula 16 teams, 5 keepers=76. Almost anything resembling a RB is kept in shula so it is easy for us to say don't keep Ronnie Brown. Is he any injury risk, you bet, but he is also a good producer on the field for however long he plays. Keep him or not? I think trade him. Hmary didn't give us the draft spot but coupling Brown with the first round pick to move up in the draft might be an idea worth exploring. This years draft doesn't offer a lot of depth a RB but maybe you move up enough to grab one of the few good ones. Point out Browns good production for the number of games he has played, project those numbers out for a full season of production and see what interest you can spark.
 
lol ! Well funny Coach should bring it up ,,,, but my first pick in this Debacle is the 4.3 :headscratch: . I traded away my first 3 rounds last year :-( . So I apologize for not adding this ,, beleive me it was not intentional for I do want correct advice . From what has been mentioned so far it is still correct in my opinion . As ar as QB's everyone is right ! each team in my league already have a QB which they will be keeping ! The likes of Eli Manning / Cassel / Ryan / Orton / Campbell / Favre / Sanchez / Lienart / Stafford /Young / Henne will all be available draft day . Right now I feel my keepers will be PT / Bush / and all 4 receivers .. Hightower/Brown /Mc Gahee / or Slaton is my dilemma as the last keeper spot ? . Been trying to move Brown but everyone I think is very leary , and all have rejected my offers ? Ive been packaging him with McGahee . I have been trying to get a late 1st rd pick for him 1.7 - 1.10 . Some say get what ever you can for Brown ! I still have a little faith in him but not to the point where I would not move him ! after all if he would not have got hurt last year he would be a top 5 rb !!! I do want to move him ! not only for the injury concern but also the age factor What do you think is a fair price for Brown ???? 2nd rd / 3rd rd pick ? HMary
 
Don't you hate it when you trade away future draft picks and then one day....BOOM....The future comes.

Kinda like buying on credit....one day you will have to pay the bill.
 
without your first 3 rounds I think you have to keep Eli. by the time you pick, you could be looking at a very ugly QB situation to pick from.
 
Miller said:
without your first 3 rounds I think you have to keep Eli. by the time you pick, you could be looking at a very ugly QB situation to pick from.
Click to expand...

kinda what i was thinking . . . and if you are able to get a better one with your 1st or early pick, you've got a solid backup or a matchup player.
 
Well Guys . Sad to say but I don't have a pick in this years draft until 4.3 . Sucks that I made alot of trades the last couple of years and this is where I ended up . By the time I draft RB's will be a crap shoot . Because of the Deep Keeper aspect ( Keeping 7 ) and the age of and injury to Ronnie Brown I am thinking about moving him via trade . Do you think this would be a wise move ? Will he be productive this year ? Maybe for picks or player plus pick ? This league has been around for 13 years and this year trading has been all but null because many of the teams are set with there 7 keepers . HM
 
try to trade ronnie brown for sure to a guy with a bad RB situation, maybe even see if you could package him with brett favre to see if you could get a high pick + a player
 
QB Eli Manning NYG
RB Pierre Thomas NO
RB Ronnie Brown MIA
RB Tim Hightower ARZ
WR Greg Jennings GB
WR Dwayne Bowe KC
WR Michael Crabtree SF
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top