Dynasty QB Rankings from FFExtreme.com

ExperiencedRookie

ExperiencedRookie

Well-Known Member
Peyton Manning
Tom Brady
Drew Brees
Aaron Rodgers
Tony Romo
Ben Roethlisberger
Philip Rivers
Jay Cutler
Matt Cassel
Carson Palmer
Matt Ryan
Mark Sanchez
Matt Schaub
Matthew Stafford
Donovan McNabb
Joe Flacco
Kurt Warner
Sage Rosenfels
Eli Manning
Matt Hasselbeck
Kyle Orton
Marc Bulger
David Garrard
Matt Leinart
Trent Edwards
Josh Freeman
Brady Quinn
JaMarcus Russell
Chad Pennington
Derek Anderson
Jake Delhomme
Kerry Collins
Pat White
Nate Davis
Jason Campbell
Kevin Kolb
Tyler Thigpen
Colt Brennan
Daunte Culpepper
Kellen Clemens
Seneca Wallace
Jon Kitna
J.T. OSullivan
Luke McCown
Chad Henne
Byron Leftwich
Vince Young
Tarvaris Jackson
Brett Ratliff
Brodie Croyle
Julian Edelman
Rhett Bomar
Tom Brandstater
Alex Smith (SF)
Shaun Hill
Brian Brohm
Quinn Gray
Andre Woodson
Andrew Walter
Jeff Garcia
Dan Orlovsky
Brooks Bollinger
Ryan Fitzpatrick
J.P. Losman
Ken Dorsey
Cleo Lemon
John Beck
John David Booty
Rex Grossman
Troy Smith

Thoughts?
 
This is an intriguing list. Looks like it keeps the top 3 fantasy QBs up at the top regardless of age.

After that it is a huge group of the young rising stars. Rodgers, Rivers, Romo, Cutler, ect ect.

Looks like a major downgrade for QBs like McNabb, Hass, and Warner, who might be more "win now" than a guy like Sanchez, Stafford, Cassel, or Big Ben.
 
I'm amazed all three Fins QBs made this list. From a dynasty perspective it makes a certain amount of sense, but I'm still surprised all three are as high as they are.
 
DearbornDolfan said:
I'm amazed all three Fins QBs made this list. From a dynasty perspective it makes a certain amount of sense, but I'm still surprised all three are as high as they are.
Click to expand...

When the 1st one comes in at 29th on the list, it doesn't speak well to the state of a teams fantasy offensive value.

As far as Pat White, I think there are a lot of people out there who think that this dude is going to be a stud on some level. He does carry a certain implied value. Whether there will be any truth to it or not is still very far off.
 
ExperiencedRookie said:
When the 1st one comes in at 29th on the list, it doesn't speak well to the state of a teams fantasy offensive value.
Click to expand...

Penny's value is down because he has to prove he can stay healthy and do it again.

I was not to surprised that White is as high as he is - I do think he will succeed but I think there is also a tendency to give the benefit of the doubt to highly rated rookies and move them up higher than they otherwise would be.

I was surprised that Henne did not take a dive farther down the list. Nothing against him but with the shine on White he becomes the #3.
 
ExperiencedRookie said:
This is an intriguing list. Looks like it keeps the top 3 fantasy QBs up at the top regardless of age.
Click to expand...

I personally would think Peytie and Tommy are at points in their careers where they should start to slide in a dynasty format.

Manning because of the changes across the board having a negative impact at some level.

Brady is recovering from an injury and it at least appears he may have more off field distractions.
 
Cooley Cadets said:
I personally would think Peytie and Tommy are at points in their careers where they should start to slide in a dynasty format.

Manning because of the changes across the board having a negative impact at some level.

Brady is recovering from an injury and it at least appears he may have more off field distractions.
Click to expand...

What QBs could find their way ahead of these guys then?
 
Peyton Manning - read it here first - this is the beginning of a slide
Tom Brady - The likes of Moss doesn't hurt but he does not return to all of his former glory
Drew Brees - He has done better than I have antcipated in the league
Aaron Rodgers - Would take him before the top 2
Tony Romo - I would have him drop
Ben Roethlisberger - He would drop but not as far as Romo
Philip Rivers - Should bump up a few spots, look what he has done w/ just Gates
Jay Cutler - Not his biggest fan but by the same token not looking at bumping him down far if at all either
Matt Cassel - It's a gamble but I could see him succeed (may not come immediately but should hold his own from the start)
Carson Palmer - Concerned with him coming off the injury but this is far enough of a drop
Matt Ryan - If Cassel is a gamble so is the expectation that Ryan will perform consistently like or improve on his rookies season. It's a gamble I would be willing to take
Mark Sanchez - Not a fan but I am not sure I would bump him down even though I would likely pass on him personally
Matt Schaub - I was one of those high on him when he came into town but injury and no investment in a #2 WR or a pass catching TE has rubbed some of the shine off. Where I had him higher before this is about right now.
Matthew Stafford - For those new to my posts I am a Lion fan. Of course he goes higher - definitely before Sanchez.
Donovan McNabb - The past few years there has been talk about him being run out of town, not sure a playoff run will be enough to change that for long. I could see him going higher but going this low is not unreasonable either
Joe Flacco - Beginning of a lower tier - definitely would prefer as my #2 QB
Kurt Warner - Anyone hearing G or g god has me 2nd guessing the return on my investment
Sage Rosenfels - Not this high thank you
Eli Manning - Seems a little low, borderline solid #1 fantasy QB
Matt Hasselbeck - I'm looking for a shortterm revival so if I have a young #1 I would be more willing to take a shot here
Kyle Orton - I'll have to see something in Denver before I would give serious consideration
Marc Bulger - Not bad but the glory days of the team and him are past
David Garrard - Would prefer him as a #3 than a #2
Matt Leinart - Never seemed to have his head on the game
Trent Edwards - Would say he will never be flashy but should be pretty solid but TO may give him a season with a little flash
Josh Freeman - Project so he would have to be my #3 but I could see him being pushed into playing early in his career
Brady Quinn - Should be higher but I can understand why he is not since everyone has been questioning his ability since entering the league and have still not seen enough to confirm the + or -
JaMarcus Russell - I bought the rookie year but have since traded him away and am not looking at giving him another shot on my roster any time soon
Chad Pennington - See Trent Edwards w/o the TO comment
Derek Anderson - Would move up a bump if starting somewhere else
Jake Delhomme - Good value for your #3 shortterm
Kerry Collins - Another good value but not a longterm option
Pat White - Take him if you can stash him
Nate Davis - To high
Jason Campbell - Should get a bump for starting - this low because of the mindset now that he is not wanted
Kevin Kolb - If Nab's boo birds come out he should start to climb
Tyler Thigpen - If his situation changes he could climb as well but not as sure as with Kolb that is likely
Colt Brennan - Has to see the field before he can really do any climbing
Daunte Culpepper - Only if you plan on using him as an emergency backup for 1-2 years unless the lost weight really was all it took for him to regain his mobility...
Kellen Clemens - No thanks
Seneca Wallace - If you have Hass and he goes down he would be a good investment (and should be available)
Jon Kitna - I could see him replacing Romo just would not expect it

Of the rest alot depends on their situation - bumps if starting or showing improvement to consider them potential starters down the road.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top