The Lineup Doctor 2010

[Bank Barth]

WR/RB Position

Basic Scoring- WR/RB Position

Forsett (Sea-RB) vs San Fran
Aromashodu (Chi-WR) vs Det
Mike Williams (Sea-WR) vs San Fran
Eddie Royal (Den-WR) vs Jac

Who should I start Week 1?

 

[chrisslabaugh]

Standard Scoring No PPR: Pick three out of these 4 RB's C.J, Benson, A. Foster, D. Will.
Also in a seperate league same scoring system I need 2 Rb's 2 Wr's and a flex: RB's: Gore, Barber, Benson, also have M. Bush but I'm not considering him. Wr's: Roddy White, Nicks, Welker, and H. Ward. Thanks appreciate the help

CJ, Benson, D/Will.... I'm not sold on Foster yet go with your studs

Gore is a must start, Benson again, Roddy is a must start and I would go with Hines. Dixon is a better QB then most will give him credit for. He was solid in his only start last year and that was against a very tough defense. Nicks will be solid for your flex.

 

[chrisslabaugh]

Basic Scoring- WR/RB Position

Forsett (Sea-RB) vs San Fran
Aromashodu (Chi-WR) vs Det
Mike Williams (Sea-WR) vs San Fran
Eddie Royal (Den-WR) vs Jac

Who should I start Week 1?

A whole lot of question marks here..... I think Aromashodu is the safest play.

 

[mudloggerone]

Chris would you trade Calvin Johnson for S Jackson in a ppr legue if CJ was your 2 and Foster was your #1 RB and more questions at that position behind him?

 

[chrisslabaugh]

Chris would you trade Calvin Johnson for S Jackson in a ppr legue if CJ was your 2 and Foster was your #1 RB and more questions at that position behind him?

I'm not a Jackson fan myself and have avoided him in all my drafts. I think you built that team that way for a reason and should use a wait and see approach before you make any earth shattering moves to see exactly how it pans out. You might be surprised how good it really is.

 

[2minutedrill]

Hey Chris - when you trade romo at this point? i'm weak at wr and would try to get a #1 wr in return plus a bu qb. (big ben is current bu) my other wr's are Mason, driver, wallace and a broken s.rice(from Miaphins).

 

[chrisslabaugh]

Hey Chris - when you trade romo at this point? i'm weak at wr and would try to get a #1 wr in return plus a bu qb. (big ben is current bu) my other wr's are Mason, driver, wallace and a broken s.rice(from Miaphins).

I believe that Big Ben will play like a #1 QB when his suspension is over so I do think this would be a good move. In leagues which award 6 pts for TD passes QB is very valuable so make sure you are getting equal value. Some owners view of a #1 WR is quite different then others. I would not settle for anything less then a top 12 WR. You might have to throw in a filler type player to get the b/u QB though.

 

[mudloggerone]

I'm not a Jackson fan myself and have avoided him in all my drafts. I think you built that team that way for a reason and should use a wait and see approach before you make any earth shattering moves to see exactly how it pans out. You might be surprised how good it really is.

I'm sure glad that you have the same thoughts as me on this trade Chris.

 

[Baldie]

Basic Scoring league.......WR-RB-RB-TE-T/WR-WR/RB

RB
Mendenhall vs ATL
Moreno @ JAX
Stewart @ NYG
Gore @ Sea

WR
Fitzgerald @ STL
Ochocinco @ NE
Crabtree @ Sea
Sims-Walker vs Den
Boldin @ NYJ
Harvin @ NO

Donation made!

 

[chrisslabaugh]

Mendy, Stewart, Gore, Fitz, Ocho

I think these are your safest choices for this week.

 

[Baldie]

This is the 2nd league I'm in....basic scoring....WR-WR-RB-RB-W/T/R

WR
Austin @ Wash
Driver @ Phil
Breaston @ StL
Colston vs Min
Garcon @ Hous
RB
Peterson @ NO
Brown @ Buf
Stewart @ NYG
Bradshaw vs Car
Maroney vs Cin

Donation has been made.....

 

[chrisslabaugh]

This is the 2nd league I'm in....basic scoring....WR-WR-RB-RB-W/T/R

WR
Austin @ Wash
Driver @ Phil
Breaston @ StL
Colston vs Min
Garcon @ Hous
RB
Peterson @ NO
Brown @ Buf
Stewart @ NYG
Bradshaw vs Car
Maroney vs Cin

Donation has been made.....

WR's- Colston and Austin
RB's Peterson and Brown
Flex- Garcon

(I was torn between Garcon and Stewart but think that the Carolina offense is going to struggle early and Stewart hasn't really played at all in the preseason. Shootout in Indy should mean good numbers for Garcon)

 

[Trickster]

Gaffney or Bowe as my WR3??

 

[chrisslabaugh]

Gaffney or Bowe as my WR3??

Bowe is a great #3 and I'd play him until he gives me reason not to or until Gafney proves too good to bench

 

[Escrow]

PPR=1
1 Point for 10 yards rush/rec
1 points for 25 kr/pr yards
6 for td

Pick one for RB2

Spiller vs MIA-O
Hightower vs STL


I also have forsett and MBIII, neither warrant a start this week.

 

[chrisslabaugh]

PPR=1
1 Point for 10 yards rush/rec
1 points for 25 kr/pr yards
6 for td

Pick one for RB2

Spiller vs MIA-O
Hightower vs STL


I also have forsett and MBIII, neither warrant a start this week.

Beanie is dinged up and Arizona is facing St. Louis this week. I'm not so sure Spiller gets a ton of return opportunities now that he sits atop the depth chart. Hightower is a nice play this week.

 

[Phil Dawson]

QB, receivers and flex?

In a .5 ppr with 6 points for all TDs including passing, -3 for
interceptions and -3 for fumbles the rest standard:

Derek Andersen or Kevin Kolb?

I also have 2RB spots 3 WR spots and one WR/RB for Austin, Boldin,
Breaston, Gaffney, Collie, Rice, Charles, Sproles and Forsett. I'm
going with Austin, Rice and Charles. Who gets the other 3 spots?

Thanks,

 

[chrisslabaugh]

Kevin Kolb despite a seemingly difficult matchup. I have no faith in Derek Anderson right now.

Charles, Gafney and Collie.

 

[Escrow]

12 team PPR
1 point for 10 yards rush/rec
1 PPR
1 Point for 20 yards passing
1 Point for 25 return yards
6 for TD(any kind)
Bonus' for 100 yards rush/rec, 300 yards passing


QB- Schaub
RB- D Will, Spiller, MBII, Hightower, Forsett
WR - Moss, Smith(Car), Crabtree, Tampa Williams, Cribbs
TE- Z Miller(Oak), KWIII

Would you drop anyone for Leon Washington?

 

[chrisslabaugh]

12 team PPR
1 point for 10 yards rush/rec
1 PPR
1 Point for 20 yards passing
1 Point for 25 return yards
6 for TD(any kind)
Bonus' for 100 yards rush/rec, 300 yards passing


QB- Schaub
RB- D Will, Spiller, MBII, Hightower, Forsett
WR - Moss, Smith(Car), Crabtree, Tampa Williams24, Cribbs
TE- Z Miller(Oak), KWIII

Would you drop anyone for Leon Washington?

Can't say that I would unfortunately. The closest would be Hightower but he's looking like he could be pretty nice at least for the start of the season.