Grade my draft!!!

[Catch Freaks]

I would like to get some incite into what everyone thinks of my team. We are to start 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 TE, 1 RB/WR/TE, 1 K & 1 DEF/ST.

I have:

QB-Matt Cassel & Shaun Hill

RB-Steve Slaton, Marion Barber, Ray Rice, Leon Washington, Rashad Jennings

WR-Larry Fitzgerald, Eddie Royal, Vincent Jackson, Percy Harvin, Greg Camarillo

TE-John Carlson & Desmond Clark

K-Robbie Gould

DEF-Philadelphia Eagles

This is a 14-team league too.

 

[chrisslabaugh]

QB's are pretty weak
RB's pretty solid
Wr's good-very good depending on if this is a ppr league
TE- I like Carlson a lot but Clark isn't even a starter this year
K and DEF- doesn't matter

 

[Catch Freaks]

This is a ppr league, but the Clark @ TE was a second-to-last round pick.

 

[chrisslabaugh]

Slaton and Barber are even better in ppr. Overall pretty good team for 14 team league

 

[tblGoBlue]

I think this is a great team... how on earth did you end up with Fitzgerald, Slaton, and Barber in a 14 team league?! Only thing I would worry about is the QB.

 

[Catch Freaks]

I took Fitz @ the 3rd pick and slaton fell to me in the 2nd round. I took Barber in the 3rd. I am looking into trading with a guy to get either Aaron Rodgers or Jay Cutler though.

 

[tblGoBlue]

that's very far for slaton to fall... nice pickup! Let us know what kind of trade you work out or if you need any advice on that.

 

[ExperiencedRookie]

Everyone give him bad advice.

Catch Freaks and I are in this league together....

My team is easily better!!

Yeah that's right Nick!

My squad is :

QB : McNabb, Hasselbeck
RB : Moreno, McFadden, Felix Jones, Jerome Harrison, Chester Taylor
WR : Randy Moss, Steve Smith, Torry Holt, Hakeem Nicks, Nate Burleson
TE : Antonio Gates

 

[Catch Freaks]

Everyone give him bad advice.

Catch Freaks and I are in this league together....

My team is easily better!!

Yeah that's right Nick!

My squad is :

QB : McNabb, Hasselbeck
RB : Moreno, McFadden, Felix Jones, Jerome Harrison, Chester Taylor
WR : Randy Moss, Steve Smith, Torry Holt, Hakeem Nicks, Nate Burleson
TE : Antonio Gates

Are you serious? McNabb, Hasselbeck are better than mine, but my RB's kill yours.

WR's are about a wash considering I have Fitzy.

TE you have me beat, but not my a ton. I still have a top-10 TE though.

 

[tblGoBlue]

I'd take Catch Freaks team here... sorry ER.

 

[Sgt John]

QB-Matt Cassel & Shaun Hill
RB-Steve Slaton, Marion Barber, Ray Rice, Leon Washington, Rashad Jennings
WR-Larry Fitzgerald, Eddie Royal, Vincent Jackson, Percy Harvin, Greg Camarillo
TE-John Carlson & Desmond Clark
K-Robbie Gould
DEF-Philadelphia Eagles

The QBs are middle of the road, but they will get something done for you each week. Nothing fancy.

The RBs are exceptional. This is a great collection of talent who should reap you much rewards.

WR - Fabulous top 3 with Fitz, Royal, and Harvin. VJ doesnt waive my flag and Camarillo is behind Bess right now, but Camarillo rates as waiver wire fodder to me.

TEs are pretty good. Carlson works great and Clark, though not the #1, is still slated to see some receptions.

Philly D - Not bad.

 

[Sgt John]

QB : McNabb, Hasselbeck
RB : Moreno, McFadden, Felix Jones, Jerome Harrison, Chester Taylor
WR : Randy Moss, Steve Smith, Torry Holt, Hakeem Nicks, Nate Burleson
TE : Antonio Gates

QB - McNabb has top 5 potential this year IF he holds up and IF the injuries and camp stop. Hass is a great filler. If he returns to form I like the ability to play the matchups every week.

RB - Not really waiving my flag. This is a collection of POTENTIAL, but thats not going to buy the groceries. You need Moreno to get his rump in camp.

WR - Not a bad 1-2 punch with Nicks and Moss. Decent depth

TE - Fabulous. Thats all that needs to be said.

DEF - Terrible. Ive never heard of the "blanks"

 

[Catch Freaks]

The QBs are middle of the road, but they will get something done for you each week. Nothing fancy.

The RBs are exceptional. This is a great collection of talent who should reap you much rewards.

WR - Fabulous top 3 with Fitz, Royal, and Harvin. VJ doesnt waive my flag and Camarillo is behind Bess right now, but Camarillo rates as waiver wire fodder to me.

TEs are pretty good. Carlson works great and Clark, though not the #1, is still slated to see some receptions.

Philly D - Not bad.

From what I've been hearing is that Cassel is the real deal in KC. They say he looks like a veteran and not like a one-year wonder.

 

[cctekguy]

From what I've been hearing is that Cassel is the real deal in KC. They say he looks like a veteran and not like a one-year wonder.

All I can tell you is you better drop Dwayne Bowe and pick up Brad Cottam. :sad:

 

[Catch Freaks]

All I can tell you is you better drop Dwayne Bowe and pick up Brad Cottam. :sad:

I don't have Bowe and Cottam is taken by another team in our draft.

KC did pick up Amani Toomer in the offseason and having Mark Bradley and Bowe back means some veteran WR's. Plus Toomer was a great possession receiver in New York.

 

[cctekguy]

All I can tell you is you better drop Dwayne Bowe and pick up Brad Cottam. :sad:

It was a lame analogy implying that you should not look for Cassel to excel on deep routes and to make a lot of "dump offs" to the short guy.