Charles for Nicks?

[gruntbusters]

I've been offered J Charles for H Nicks. 10 Team PPR dynasty league. I own Cruz and Hillis. Worried about Charles acl injury and how strong he might come back. But then again Nicks has been fragile. I'm inclined to hang onto Nicks but I also do not have a RB1 on my team outside of S Greene. Thoughts?

 

[jjtweeks]

I do it with your circumstances

 

[mudloggerone]

I'd have to do it as well if I was stuck with Green as my RB 1.

 

[gruntbusters]

I think I'll shop Nicks around a little. Do you guys see Charles as a top 10 PPR RB?

 

[Phicinfan]

I think I'll shop Nicks around a little. Do you guys see Charles as a top 10 PPR RB?

I do, especially with Hillis there to pound defenses senseless and make Charles that much more effective when he comes in. Could be Sproles part two

 

[gruntbusters]

Upon shopping mr Nicks a bit, it's possible that I could retain T Richardson in the exchange. You guys higher on him than Charles? Age 21, great situation on a bad team. Can he catch as well as run? Don't know if he's a complete back.

Hate to lose Nicks, I bought the jersey a couple of years ago heh....

Here's my team for what it's worth:
QB
Tony Romo, DAL
Matt Schaub HOU
Brandon Weeden, CLE
John Skelton, ARI

RB
Roy Helu Jr. WAS
Peyton Hillis CLE
Shonn Greene NYJ
Lamar Miller, MIA
Ronnie Hillman, DEN
LaGarette Blount TB
Bilal Powell NYJ

WR
Hakeem Nicks NYG
Brandon Marshall MIA
Victor Cruz NYG
Antonio Brown PIT
Nate Burleson, DET
Jacoby Ford OAK
Lance Moore NO
Emmanual Sanders PIT
Juron Criner, OAK
David Gettis, CAR
Roberto Wallace, MIA
Andre Caldwell, DEN
Armon Binns, CIN
Lestar Jean, HOU

TE
Rob Gronkowski NE
Tony Gonzolaz ATL
Lance Kendricks StL
DJ Williams, GB

D
Von Miller DEN
Jarod Mayo NE
Pat Angerer IND
Colin McCarthy, TEN
Sean Lee DAL
Daryl Washington, ARI

 

[Miller]

If you can get TR in a dynasty league for Nicks, do it now before he changes his mind. I LOVE that trade for your team. I am not a fan of Charles and would retain Nicks over him....but for Richardson, in a heartbeat!

 

[Phicinfan]

If you can get TR in a dynasty league for Nicks, do it now before he changes his mind. I LOVE that trade for your team. I am not a fan of Charles and would retain Nicks over him....but for Richardson, in a heartbeat!

I would do both, but for Richardson...YUP, YUP

 

[mudloggerone]

Agree with PhiCin.

 

[Arctic Dawgs]

Yup, Not high on Charles, but if Dynasty/Keeper Richardson in a heartbeat

 

[gruntbusters]

Any concern for Richardsons knees?

 

[Miller]

no, not at all.

 

[paperstacks1980]

I'd do it.

 

[Phicinfan]

Any concern for Richardsons knees?

I have less concern for Richardson's and Charles' knees, then I do for Nicks in general

 

[mudloggerone]

What PhiCin said, once again.

 

[gruntbusters]

Coach with Richardson isn't getting back to me here in a timely manner...may have to pull the trigger on Charles. Coach has another deal dependent on this one. So not even sure if it'll fly. Thanks guys for you input...sometimes it's good to see some opinions to make sure you're not way off in left field.